Introductions:
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Double Toro isn’t just another Nicaraguan cigar—it’s a handcrafted statement of balance, depth, and quality. If you’ve been in the cigar game long enough, you know this stick carries a reputation. And if you haven’t smoked one yet, buckle up—it’s time to find out why this box-pressed beauty keeps showing up on “Best Cigars of the Year” lists.
the Oliva Serie V Melanio Double Toro isn’t just a cigar — it’s an experience. Crafted for seasoned smokers, this full-bodied Nicaraguan blend offers bold spice, creamy chocolate, and a slow burn that demands your attention.
This review covers everything you need to know: the flavor profile, construction, draw, burn, pairing suggestions, and whether it’s worth the price tag. (Spoiler: it is.)
First Impressions:
- Size: 6 x 60 (Double Toro)
- Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra
- Box-pressed: Yes
- Binder & Filler: Nicaraguan
- MSRP: ~$15–$18 per stick
The cigar feels luxurious before you even light it. The wrapper is smooth, chocolate brown, slightly oily, and firmly packed. There are minimal veins, tight seams, and a triple cap that tells you this wasn’t rolled by an amateur.
The pre-light aroma is rich—earthy with notes of dark chocolate, black pepper, and cedar.
Flavor Notes:
First Third
Right from the start, you’re hit with a bold mix of black pepper and earth, followed by leather and espresso. The retrohale amplifies that peppery spice but doesn’t overpower. The smoke output is generous and creamy. There’s a subtle sweetness, almost like dark cherry hiding behind the intensity.
Second Third
This is where the cigar truly opens up. The pepper dies down slightly and makes room for baking spices—cinnamon, nutmeg—and rich cocoa. A subtle nutty undertone develops, giving the cigar balance. Every draw feels intentional, measured. The construction is holding up beautifully.
Final Third
The strength increases, as expected. The sweetness fades and you’re left with bold cedar, roasted coffee bean, and a heavy leathery finish. It’s not harsh—just commanding. This is where the complexity shines. You’ll want to slow down and enjoy the last third like the final few sips of a great bourbon.First Third: Earthy with hints of cedar and black pepper
Burn & Draw:
Burn: Laser-straight. No relights or touch-ups needed over 90 minutes.
Ash: Holds tight—white/gray and stacked like coins.
Draw: Slight resistance, but consistent and clean.
Smoke Time: 90–110 minutes depending on how fast you puff.
This is a cigar built for patience. Rush it, and you’ll miss the beauty of its transitions. Take your time, and you’ll experience one of the best-constructed sticks in the game.Razor-sharp burn. Tight but consistent draw. This isn’t a cigar you rush — it’s one you reflect with.
Strength & Complexity:
- Body: Full
- Strength: Medium-Full to Full
- Complexity: 9/10
If you’re new to cigars, this isn’t the stick to start with. But for intermediate to advanced smokers, the Melanio Double Toro delivers a masterclass in blending and balance.
Pairing Recommendation:
- Drink: Single malt scotch (like GlenDronach 15), a bold bourbon (like Eagle Rare), or black coffee
- Time of Day: Evening, post-dinner, or weekend lounge sessions
- Occasion: Celebrations, big wins, or moments you want to slow down and savor
Verdict:
Score: 9.3/10
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Double Toro is not just a top-tier cigar—it’s a benchmark. For those who appreciate Nicaraguan power with Ecuadorian finesse, this is one of the best cigars under $20 you’ll ever smoke.
Flavor Complexity: Excellent Construction: Flawless Price-to-Performance: Worth every penny
Whether you’re stocking your humidor or searching for a perfect gift cigar for another aficionado, this should be in your rotation. Just don’t light it on the golf course—you’ll want to sit and savor every inch.9.3/10. The Melanio Double Toro earns its premium reputation. Pair it with a glass of single malt or sit back with your favorite playlist.
English